limlim:I think going by the principle of 'what is in the child's best welfare' is fair. However that may hold different meanings for different parents. I may not mind my child taking an extra 15 mins to get home if the school environment (academic standards, religious formation or lack thereof etc) suits him. To me, it might be in his best welfare to 'waste' that extra 15 mins as he would get a better education, at least by my standards.The parents made the choice. What more do you want to say?beanstalk:
It works both ways. Religion is a sensitive issue and for those who subscribe to one, it can be very emotional. It is very hard to say if a Christian child should be deprived of a Christian education simply because his/her parents chose to reside outside of 2 km of a school. Singapore is small, 'outside 2 km' could mean 2.5 or 20 km. With expressways, and a car, a kid living outside of 2 km may actually reach home the same time as someone walking home a few blocks away.
You value religious faith in lessons, Other value their sleep/health. Why should you be given priority over the others?
Why should connection be valued over practicality?
And children are not deprive of their religious beliefs.. They can attend church every week or every day if they like. No body stops them. For your own convenience of having the religious teachings in the school instead of separately in the church, you deprive others of practical convenience. Is this fair?
And the expressway example.. the users on cars is jamming up the roads causing much inconvenience to other road users, in the morning and evening.
It is not always possible for people to move within 1 km of a school. Some people simply cannot afford to.
There is a bit of misunderstanding here...the religious teaching at school is not intended to replace that provided by places of worship. It reinforces the latter. For people in that religion, it is important that their kids receive consistent messaging. A secular educational environment teaches values but does not associate the values with spirituality, which some people would want for their kids. This is a need that may be as important to one parent as it is for another whose kid needs alot of sleep. I don't think you should attribute selfish intentions to people without really knowing them. Much worse, to even accuse them of religious hypocrisy because of this.
The present system has checks to encourage diversity in a school and that's a good thing in the national interest. I guess with the caps, each group thinks it should have a bigger piece of the pie than they currently have. That includes you and me. I believe we both have valid concerns.