@rinsider We had a discussion about this last night, with some friends (also parents)!
Among our group, we have one neighbourhood sec school teacher and one allied educator.
Some points:
Girls bully as well, so what’s the punitive measures for them, and are these effective? Or we are sticking with less-effective measures for girls, due to their perceived physical vulnerability?
What teachers see on the ground: the victim may not be adequately supported, especially if they are bullied in their graduating year and leave the school after that. Gentler measures such as corrective work don’t have much effect. Getting teens to help out in school (e.g. cleaning toilets) requires plenty of time and effort from already overstretched teachers.
It’s unrealistic/unfair to expect teachers to do double-duty as therapists, coaches. Teachers are not experts in behavioural change. Perhaps every school needs a dedicated team to handle these non-academic challenges, not just a handful of counsellors?
Will school caning, the way it is currently carried out, really serve as a bullying deterrent, or is it performative?
We talked about the whistleblowing aspect as well. We know of teachers who are alerted to fights and they personally intervene. But not everyone has that relationship with their students, and that’s not a real solution.
We also talked about victims, especially male victims, who may not talk to anyone about what they’re facing.