2014 P1 Registration Exercise for 2015 In-Take
-
appreciate if someone could advise how 2Cs works? is it also priority for SC and by distance? getting a bit nervous as we are the unfortunate one that need balloting for 2C. Thanks in advance.
-
Poptart:
a lot of parents will object & protest, if you forbid them to withdraw.
I think this is a suggestion worth taking note.FQW:
Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there's a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can't go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
Just throwing up some suggestions. Please don't wallop me hur (I'm not one of the four).
In my humble view,phase 2A1/2 are already in a privileged position.
\"Chope-ing\" a place in in 2A phase and still hoping to get a better deal at later phases will really put parents in phase 2C in a further disadvantageous situation.
because who are the people who withdraw / come out of Phase 1 (sibling) or Phase 2A, to register under 2B schools ?
will be many parents, that have connection to the schools :-
- Parent Volunteers tied to their respective primary schools,
- Grass Root leaders from the various HDB Residential Committee / Private Condominium Neighbourhood Committee, doing community service work for their GRC, at hospitals, or perform duties during festive seasons (eg: distribute moon cakes to the old folks, or follow their MP on entourage to Yu Hua Yuan in Jurong, during Mid Autumn festival) etc.
- plus several volunteers offering their time in Hokkien Clan association, Teochew Clan association, Buddhist temples at Guang Ming Shan (Bright Hill road) + other related temple affliated to Buddhist schools, plus those members from Catholic churches / Methodist / Presbyterian / Anglican churches affliated to respective primary schools. -
[quote="FQW"]Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there’s a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can’t go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
Just throwing up some suggestions. Please don’t wallop me hur (I’m not one of the four).
I think this is a suggestion worth taking note.
In my humble view,phase 2A1/2 are already in a privileged position.
"Chope-ing" a place in in 2A phase and still hoping to get a better deal at later phases will really put parents in phase 2C in a further disadvantageous situation.
a lot of parents will object & protest, if you forbid them to withdraw.
because who are the people who withdraw / come out of Phase 1 (sibling) or Phase 2A, to register under 2B schools ?
will be many parents, that have connection to the schools :-
- Parent Volunteers tied to their respective primary schools,
- Grass Root leaders from the various HDB Residential Committee / Private Condominium Neighbourhood Committee, doing community service work for their GRC, at hospitals, etc.
- plus several volunteers offering their time in Hokkien Clan association, Teochew Clan association, Buddhist temples at Guang Ming Shan (Bright Hill road) + other related temple affliated to Buddhist schools, plus those members from Catholic churches / Methodist / Presbyterian / Anglican churches affliated to respective primary schools.[/quote]
Would it not make these parents consider their choice more carefully before registering?
Still there is no foolproof system that will please all parents . But it can certainly be more equitable -
for Phase 2C -
for parents outside 1 km from Popular schools : is very scary, in that last hour (3.30 pm to 4.30 pm)
after 3 pm, tension very high !
you see a lot of parents standing outside Registration hall, camping around the white board, taking photo shoot of the latest number of registrants reported, using their mobile hand phone.
every 10 to 15 minutes or so -
the P1 Officer on duty will appear and update the white board with the latest report: indicating how many SC / PR registered within 1 km, between 1 to 2 km and outside 2 km.
for parents outside 2 km -
each time an extra registrant within 1 km or between 1 to 2 km, turn up to register, your heart beat very fast.
you get anxious, because the number of vacancies available for balloting … keep dropping and dropping, getting smaller and smaller. -
Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there’s a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can’t go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
Just throwing up some suggestions. Please don’t wallop me hur (I’m not one of the four).
I think this is a suggestion worth taking note.
In my humble view,phase 2A1/2 are already in a privileged position.
"Chope-ing" a place in in 2A phase and still hoping to get a better deal at later phases will really put parents in phase 2C in a further disadvantageous situation.
I guess sometimes these parents in 2A etc got not much of choices.
If they live near very popular schools, their chances of snagging a place in 2C will be pretty low. At least in 2A , chances will be so much higher but might incur long travelling time.
So when comes to 2C , if chances of getting into a popular school within 1 km is high, I am sure parents will go for it due to less travelling time. -
Poptart:
I feel the same...once the parent has registered the child in phase 1/2A/2B, they should not be allowed to de-register after that.FQW:
Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there's a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can't go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
-
janet_lee88:
I feel the same...once the parent has registered the child in phase 1/2A/2B, they should not be allowed to de-register after that.[/quote]I agree to this idea by FQW.Poptart:
[quote=\"FQW\"]Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there's a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can't go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
Just like in DSA, once a student accepts the CO from a school, they cannot change so that there would be less uncertainties for others. The same principle applies.
People always talk about leveling the playing field for P1 registration, this is definitely one way because some have a few means(like bao-jiat durians) to get into different popular schools and some only have one way. By doing this, it is indirectly limiting everyone to just one way, would that not be more equal in terms of opportunity?
Based on current rules, I have to agree that the 4 parents were just playing by the rules and were valid in their actions and perhaps with valid reasons too. -
janet_lee88:
I feel the same...once the parent has registered the child in phase 1/2A/2B, they should not be allowed to de-register after that.[/quote]Poptart:
[quote=\"FQW\"]Would it make the whole P1 reg process less stressful if there's a rule to state that if someone reg at an earlier phase (e.g. P2B), once that phase has passed, he can't go back to de-register to apply to a later phase when opportunity arises.
Bottom line, for those that have secured a place prior to 2C and giving it up for whatever reason is also taking a big risk. P2C itself is very competitive especially for popular schools, for those that have withdrawn, it is back to square one, everybody is on even ground.
For popular school, If you are more than 1km, by default chances of balloting is low and even if there is balloting, the chances itself is also very low. -
I don’t think there is a need to prevent pple from withdrawing from earlier phases to try at 2C. It’s fair game coz they will also be taking a risk and releasing seats to others who want it more.
MOE just needs to listen to Chief Kiasu and make over-subscribed schools stop all active applications by the end of 2nd day, and on the last day, only allow those who dun qualify for balloting to withdraw and go to other schools that still have places.
Ultimately, the distance rule should prevail for the good of the child. -
some reserve places in the earlier phases for peace of mind…then monitor situation at phase 2C. it is a big risk to de-register and then register…in that split second, the vacancy can be snapped up. it’s giving up a place and then taking up another seat elsewhere.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login